Obtain free Meals Costs updates
We’ll ship you a myFT Day by day Digest e-mail rounding up the newest Meals Costs information each morning.
The quantity that almost all UK farmers are paid for milk has plunged under their manufacturing prices, exacerbating considerations over the viability of small dairy farms.
Arla and Muller, Britain’s two largest dairy processors, lower their “farmgate value” for 5 consecutive months, with Arla holding the value at 35p a litre in June and July, down 29 per cent from 49p in February. Muller pays 38p a litre in contrast with 47p 5 months in the past.
The autumn within the quantity paid by dairy processors, intermediaries between farms and retailers, is a results of a worldwide oversupply and drop in demand for dairy, in addition to the worldwide downward pattern out there value of agricultural commodities, which customers have but to see mirrored on grocery store cabinets.
However farmers and trade our bodies warned that the sustained drop was compounding an already troublesome enterprise local weather and that clients must pay extra for milk if farmers had been to interrupt even.
“We’re on the mercy of markets,” mentioned Chris Wooden, a dairy farmer close to Penrith, Cumbria, who provides Arla. “Everyone is on about meals inflation however we’ve received inflation too. We’ve received to reside.”
The federal government is more and more involved concerning the excessive charge of meals value inflation, which stood at 18.3 per cent in Might. The Treasury introduced on Wednesday that it could scrutinise the profits of companies in the food industry supply chain.
Amid widespread value rises, milk is among the few staples displaying indicators of deflation, elevating hopes that customers will quickly profit from plummeting commodity costs.
In April, the typical value of 1 pint of milk fell by 2p to 68p, in keeping with the Workplace for Nationwide Statistics, the primary decline since Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February final yr led costs to soar. The value remained unchanged in Might.
Andrew Opie, director of meals and sustainability on the British Retail Consortium, a commerce physique, mentioned milk’s quick provide chain meant decrease vitality and commodity prices could possibly be handed on extra shortly to consumers than for merchandise made with a number of elements or requiring manufacturing.
However marginally cheaper milk in outlets isn’t any comfort for farmers, who’re contending with the lower in earnings from dairy processors in addition to traditionally excessive enter costs.
Wooden mentioned that whereas his fertiliser costs had halved, he was paying £310 a tonne for cattle feed. That’s up from £214 earlier than the Ukraine warfare, primarily based on a contract signed in October final yr when costs had been beginning to drop from their peak of £1,000.
Farmers benefited from the surge in milk costs in March final yr when feed and fertiliser prices soared, forcing processors to pay extra to make sure a gentle provide. On the market’s peak in December, farmers had been paid greater than 50p a litre, however provide has now recovered.
Susie Stannard, dairy analyst on the Agriculture and Horticulture Growth Board (AHDB), an advisory physique to British farmers, mentioned falling costs had been being pushed by “a slight improve in international provide and a lower in international demand, every of lower than 1 per cent”.
Ash Amirahmadi, Arla’s outgoing managing director, mentioned UK demand for dairy dropped final yr due to excessive meals inflation however was displaying indicators of restoration.
“The present value we’re paying our farmers is under the prices of manufacturing . . . And since a proportion of the milk goes into the globally traded commodity markets — it’s people who have crashed — that’s having a drag-down impact [on prices],” mentioned Amirahmadi. He added {that a} extended dry spell in addition to the tight labour market was including to stress on the dairy sector.
Muller mentioned its value reductions had been a results of “market pressures coupled with provide being forward of forecast”. However trade figures cautioned that if costs stayed low, farmers would have little incentive to feed their cows to provide extra milk, inflicting volumes to fall.
“We’re anticipating that dairy manufacturing will sluggish and go into destructive,” mentioned John Allen, managing guide at dairy adviser Kite, including that costs weren’t more likely to fall additional within the coming months.
The variety of dairy farmers in Britain has fallen 4.8 per cent prior to now yr, in keeping with knowledge from AHDB, leaving about 7,500 by April. Most vulnerable to closure or being subsumed into bigger companies are small and medium-sized farms that battle to make effectivity financial savings as a result of they lack the money to reinvest into their operations.
Robert Craig, a companion in three farms throughout the north of England and vice chair of processor First Milk, mentioned larger farms had been solely simply breaking even. “We aren’t being sufficiently rewarded to maintain issues as they’re . . . the one factor you’ll be able to management is effectivity, which ends up in extra intensive dairy farms and larger operations,” he mentioned.
Stannard mentioned processors would finally need to pay extra for milk with the intention to safe a gentle provide as volumes drop. Allen, in the meantime, predicted the emergence of a two-tier market wherein processors paid extra for agricultural merchandise with higher environmental credentials as meals producers took steps to chop “scope three” emissions, or greenhouse gases produced alongside a product’s complete provide chain.
Some processors already reward farmers with a premium value. Muller pays extra to farmers who meet sure situations on provide chain collaboration, herd well being and reductions in environmental impression. Arla will this yr launch environmental incentive funds for farmers.
However Craig mentioned farmers wanted surplus money to turn into sustainable in the long run. “When my grandfather began on the market had been 1 / 4 of 1,000,000 farms,” he mentioned. “When my dad took over that had halved. Once I took over it had halved once more. Is that good or dangerous?”
